Regulations, directives and decisions
Dans cette capsule
Why does an EU regulation apply directly in every country, while a directive needs national laws first? In this pill, you'll see the three binding acts of EU law, and why EU law comes first.
What makes them different? The way they bind. A regulation binds in full and applies directly in all Member States. A directive binds as to the result, and each country chooses the form and the methods. A decision binds in full, and if it names who it is addressed to, it binds only them.
Transcription
Why does an EU regulation apply directly in every country, while a directive needs national laws first? In this pill, you'll see the three binding acts of EU law, and why EU law comes first. What makes them different? The way they bind.
A regulation binds in full and applies directly in all Member States. A directive binds as to the result, and each country chooses the form and the methods. A decision binds in full, and if it names who it is addressed to, it binds only them. Think of a target and a road.
A regulation gives you the road: the same text, everywhere. A directive gives you the target: the result to achieve, and each country builds its own road through national law. And recommendations and opinions? They have no binding force at all.
Can you spot the difference in real laws? The General Data Protection Regulation is a regulation: the same rules apply directly across the Union. The NIS2 Directive on cybersecurity is a directive: each Member State had to adopt its own national measures to comply with it, by a set deadline. Is a regulation stronger than a directive?
No. Both bind. The difference is how they reach you: directly, or through national law. And when a national rule clashes with Union law, Union law takes precedence.
The Court of Justice established that principle, primacy, in Costa versus ENEL. Your turn. The Union wants rules that apply word for word, the same in every country, with no national law in between. Which act does it choose?
Pause the video and think. A regulation. It binds in full and applies directly in all Member States. A directive would leave each country to choose its own form and methods.
Your move: next time you see an EU act, read its name first. Regulation, directive or decision tells you how it binds.



