Subsidiarity and proportionality
En esta píldora
Should the Union decide something your town or your country can handle on its own? Having the power is not enough. In this pill, you'll see the two principles that decide whether, and how much, the Union acts.
What do these two principles ask? Subsidiarity asks whether the Union should act at all, or whether the Member States can do it, at central, regional or local level. Proportionality asks how much: Union action must not go beyond what is necessary.
Transcripción
Should the Union decide something your town or your country can handle on its own? Having the power is not enough. In this pill, you'll see the two principles that decide whether, and how much, the Union acts. What do these two principles ask?
Subsidiarity asks whether the Union should act at all, or whether the Member States can do it, at central, regional or local level. Proportionality asks how much: Union action must not go beyond what is necessary. The subsidiarity test has two sides. The objective cannot be sufficiently achieved by the Member States.
And it can be better achieved at Union level, because of the scale or the effects of the action. Then proportionality limits both the content and the form of the action to what the Treaties' objectives need. Who keeps an eye on subsidiarity? National parliaments.
They have eight weeks to send a reasoned opinion on a draft law. Each parliament has two votes. If objections reach one third of the votes, or a quarter in the area of freedom, security and justice, the draft must be reviewed. The Commission can then maintain, amend or withdraw it.
Does subsidiarity apply everywhere? No. It applies only in areas that are not exclusive competences of the Union. In the customs union, for example, there is nothing to split: only the Union may act there.
Your turn. The Union drafts new rules on trade with countries outside the EU. Does the principle of subsidiarity apply? Pause the video and think.
No. The common commercial policy is an exclusive competence of the Union. Subsidiarity only applies outside exclusive competence. Proportionality, though, still limits what the Union does.
Your move: when you read about a new EU proposal, ask two questions: why at EU level, and is it more than necessary?



